Just to let you know that Hungarian urban legend blogger Ivan Marinov emailed me an update on his search for the full story behind the 1926 Budapest crossword suicide case.

Ivan had, as promised, gone through the archives of various Hungarian police journals for 1926 (though the Rendőrségi Lapok-nak archive for the whole of 1926 turned out to be missing), but unfortunately without any great success. The only short article he did find was that (as I understand it) even though detectives had worked feverishly on the case for a month, they hadn’t been able to solve it: but the writer felt (somewhat downheartedly, it has to be said) that suicide had become so commonplace by then that it took attaching a crossword to one to make it noteworthy. And wasn’t it terribly sad that some people found it more interesting to make up a puzzle and die than to live?

However, this isn’t (quite) the end of the line: for example, it may well be that a Hungarian crossword history collector has a copy of this in a dusty file somewhere – or perhaps the Rendőrségi Lapok-nak 1926 archive will turn up in a completely different location. Hopefully we shall see! 🙂

Several years ago, I noted here a long-standing story about a 1926 Budapest waiter who (allegedly) killed himself, leaving a suicide note in the form of a crossword. I wondered whether it was an urban legend, or (if it were to prove to be true) whether the crossword might have been printed in a newspaper of the day. But with only a few words of tourist Hungarian to work with, I didn’t really stand a chance in the Hungarian archives.

Well, now Hungarian urban legend-hunter Marinov Iván has eagerly grabbed the baton, and hurdled his way along miles of microfilm in the newspaper archives in search of the truth. As a result, his Hungarian urban legend blog today revealed that this was indeed a real story. According to the 4th March 1926 edition of Az Est, what happened was this (forgive my rough and ready translation / paraphrasing)…


Just after (?) midnight, a man had come into the well-known Emke kávéház [Café Emke] on near the corner of Rákóczi út [Rákóczi Way] and Erzsébet körút [Elizabeth Boulevard]. After having a coffee, he repeatedly tried to call a number using the cafe’s telephone, but without success. About an hour later, the Emke’s cloakroom attendant heard a bang from a toilet: and when she opened the door, she heard a second bang. Inside, she found a young man lying on the floor with a pistol in his hand, and with blood gushing from his head and chest.


Once the ambulance and police arrived, the man’s identity was found to be Antal Gyula [Julius Anthony] of Csengery utca 3 [#3 Csengery Street]. In his pocket there was [- indeed! -] a suicide note containing a crossword. It subsequently turned out that he had lived in “misery and unemployment” for some time, and had been evicted from his apartment at the start of the month, having failed to pay his rent. But as far as his note went, the Est article concluded “A bonyolult keresztrejtvényt azonban eddig még nem sikerült megfejteni“, which I read as “the complexity of the crossword means that it has not yet been deciphered“.


So… what happened next? Iván followed up by looking in lots of other Hungarian newspapers from that year, but they all reported essentially the same bare facts, with only the Pest Newsletter adding that the man was 25 years old, and that the riddle had been “taken to police committee headquarters”. He speculates that had it might have had received more coverage had the man’s job been of higher status than a waiter: sadly, Budapest has long been (and remains to the present day, I believe) a suicide ‘hotspot’, so many other pages of those same newspapers would have contained stories of the same tragic ilk.

Ultimately, Iván failed to find any further references to the story in the newspaper archives, and so it is there that he stopped. Perhaps someone else will now pick up this baton and carry it yet further… perhaps we shall yet get to see Antal’s infamous (but tragically real) crossword!

PS: an Internet search revealed an evocative description of Café Emke in December 1945 in Sándor Márai’s autobiographical “Memoir of Hungary (1944-1948)” (pp.198-205).

Here’s a blog I found today (“Alan’s Mysterious World”) with an odd story embedded in a brief history of crossword puzzles.

Apparently, in 1926 a Budapest coffee house waiter committed suicide, leaving a blank crossword puzzle as an explanation. According to this page, a note with it said: “The solution will give you the exact reasons for my suicide and also the names of the people interested.” The police asked the public if they could help solve it, but I can’t find any reference to anyone’s having solved it.

Honestly, am I really the only person who wants to see that crossword puzzle?

Update: we now know that this really happened – here’s a 2013 update on the whole crossword suicide story.